Panel questions for Nick Agar–from Natasha Vita-More on either / or, and Ed Stein on backing up.
If you’re interested in following this debate, you can also check out some of the comments building up directly on the Youtube posting of this right here.
Here Nick moves on to uploading proper, starting with ideas about cochlear implants and the incremental move on to full uploading. Turning minds to technology, the celebration of the arrival of The Singularity in 2045, and then uploading … and why this is a bad idea!
In part 2, we get as far as the outline of Nick’s main argument, taking seriously the possibility that uploading = death. In part 3, we get the deal finished. For both, you might want to have the following handy, using your extended mind:
A = You live; benefit from bioenhancements, but forego other, significant enhancements asociated with uploading
B =You live; benefit from bioenhancements, and avoid death or replacement by a non-conscious Upload
C =You live; benefit from electronic enhancements, disease free, intellectual surge
D = You die; replaced by a machine incapable of conscious thought.
Nick Agar‘s talk at the Human Kinds Symposium focuses on Kurzweil on uploading, and gives his ideas a critical combing. Here Nick starts off with some of the basic, background ideas that Kurzweil draws on before getting ready for the view of uploading, in Part 2.
Nick’s Wikipedia page stub is here and his homepage at Victoria, Wellington, is over here.